Reforming Policing Through Changing Labor Relations: A Webinar
January 29, 2021
Sponsored by Berkeley Law, Center for Law and Work (MCLE Available!)
The Movement for Black Lives and related activism have increased discussion of profound changes in policing. This webinar will explore possible changes in labor relations law that might contribute to transforming policing. It will begin with an examination of whether the labor relations structure of policing contributes to police violence and misconduct. Do union, civil service, and statutory rights in the disciplinary process thwart transparency and accountability of police? Would increasing public information about and oversight of police working conditions and discipline reduce police misconduct? If so, what changes in the rights of police as workers might improve accountability and transparency?
Welcome and Introduction: 10:45 – 11 a.m.
Erwin Chemerinsky, Dean of Berkeley Law
Joseph Grodin, Professor Emeritus, Hastings Law and Associate Justice (Ret.) of California Supreme Court (1982-1987)
Session 1: 11 a.m. – 11: 50 p.m.: What is Different About Police Labor Relations and Does It Contribute to Police Violence Against People of Color?
In this first session of the webinar, speakers will consider the labor relations aspects of ambitious ideas for the transformation of public safety through improved transparency and accountability.
Christy E. Lopez, Professor, Georgetown Law, Co-Director Program on Innovative Policing
Ronald L. Davis, Director of Dept of Justice Office of Community Oriented Policing Services (2013-2017)
Moderator – Catherine Fisk, Berkeley Law
Keynote Address: 12:00 – 12:45 The Hon. Thelton E. Henderson (ret.), Distinguished Visitor, Berkeley Law, U.S. District Judge (1980-2017)
Based on experience overseeing the Oakland Police Department consent decree requiring reforms in training, oversight, standards for officer conduct, Judge Henderson will discuss the role of labor relations in promoting or undermining constitutional policing.
Remarks: 12:45-1:15 Nancy Skinner, California State Senator for District 9
Session 2: 1:45 p.m. – 2:45 p.m.: Transparency in the Negotiation and Administration of Police Labor Agreements
This session will consider increased transparency in the negotiation and implementation of law enforcement agencies’ policies regarding officers’ interactions with the public, especially uses of force. The panelists may consider transparency before, during, and after contract negotiations with police unions and transparency of law enforcement disciplinary processes and disciplinary records.
Will Atchison, Counsel for Law Enforcement Officers’ Unions, Portland, OR
Jon Holtzman, Renne Public Law Group, San Francisco
Anand Subramanian, PolicyLink
Moderator – Ronald Yank, former Director of the California Department of Personnel Administration, former counsel for public safety employee unions.
Session 3: 3:00 – 4:00 p.m.: Accountability
This session will consider proposals to ensure that union contracts do not prevent changes in policy aimed at respect for constitutional and civil rights. Among the topics that speakers may discuss include whether or how disciplinary processes should consider the public interest in just and nondiscriminatory policing, how agencies can impose effective discipline for misconduct, and whether or how law should require police unions fairly represent the interests of all officers.
Paul Henderson, Director of San Francisco Department of Police Accountability
Harry S. Stern, Principal, Rains, Lucia, Stern, St. Phalle & Silver
Jeanne Charles, arbitrator
Moderator: Barry Winograd, Berkeley Law lecturer, past president, National Academy of Arbitrators
Symposium Related Materials:
- Reforming Law Enforcement Labor Relations by Catherine Fisk, Joseph Grodin, Thelton Henderson, John True, Barry Winograd, and Ronald Yank.
- Police Unions by Catherine Fisk and L. Song Richardson
- Senator Skinner Press Release, Police Transaparency
- Annotated Bibliography on Police Labor Relations
- "No Pay Raise for SFPD without Reform," S.F. Chronicle, Anand Subramanian and John Crew, March 15, 2018
Bios for speakers and moderators can be found here.
Contact Pamela Erickson for more information about MCLE at firstname.lastname@example.org